Ideas and people
The family tree and the people, drawn as one. Start from an idea and see who is named on it and what it grew from; start from a person and see who they worked with and the ideas they are on. Switch layers off to see one thing clearly.
The ideas and their lineage are my family tree; the lines between people are Hugh Dubberly’s Social Graph of Cybernetics, used with credit, with his notes on his graph. Every line says where it comes from, and a lineage the sources dispute is drawn dashed or dotted. For the people alone, the people of cybernetics.
Loading the graph…
Showing the evidence: a line is drawn stronger the more sources record it. My trail is hidden. Showing my trail: a halo on what I have read, watched or written about, larger with more marks. Mine, not evidence; the lines are drawn plain. Showing both: lines by evidence, halos by my trail. The two are never added together.
Who bridges the field
The people who sit between ideas. For every pair of ideas I took the shortest routes between them over the evidence lines (lineage, who is named on what, Dubberly’s lines, who wrote which paper) and counted the share of those routes that pass through each person. Beside it, how many ideas each one is tied to. A name opens them in the graph above.
| Person | Routes through them | Ideas | People page |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Shannontheir entry | 9.2% | 4 | their entry |
| Stafford Beertheir entry | 5.1% | 3 | their entry |
| Norbert Wienertheir entry | 3.0% | 3 | their entry |
| Warren McCullochtheir entry | 1.8% | 2 | their entry |
| John von Neumanntheir entry | 1.4% | 2 | their entry |
| W. Ross Ashbytheir entry | 1.0% | 3 | their entry |
| Humberto Maturanatheir entry | 0.9% | 1 | their entry |
| Heinz von Foerstertheir entry | 0.9% | 2 | their entry |
| Gordon Pasktheir entry | 0.5% | 1 | their entry |
| W. Grey Waltertheir entry | 0.4% | 1 | their entry |
Counted at build time over the ideas and the lines between them, hops not weights. My placing (which talk or post goes with an idea) is left out, so a bridge here is the sources’ bridge, not mine.
Every idea, with its people
Era by era, as on the family tree: what each idea grew from, the people named on it, and the paper behind it where a primer covers one. An idea’s name opens it in the graph above.
Before the name 1788 to 1934 · 6
-
Ampère's cybernétique on the tree
1834 to 1843
PeopleAndré-Marie Ampère
-
Feedback amplifiers on the tree
1927 to 1945
Grew fromMaxwell, On Governors (partial)
PeopleHarold Black, Harry Nyquist, Hendrik Bode
-
Milieu intérieur to homeostasis on the tree
1865 to 1932
PeopleClaude Bernard, Walter B. Cannon
-
Maxwell, On Governors on the tree
1868
Grew fromWatt's governor
PeopleJames Clerk Maxwell
-
Servomechanisms at MIT on the tree
1934 to 1945
Grew fromMaxwell, On Governors (partial)
PeopleGordon Brown, Harold Hazen
-
1788
PeopleJames Watt, Matthew Boulton
The roots 1943 to 1956 · 9
-
Ashby, requisite variety on the tree
1948 to 1956
Grew fromMilieu intérieur to homeostasis, Ratio Club, Grey Walter's tortoises, The Macy conferences (partial)
PeopleW. Ross Ashby
PaperRequisite Variety
-
Craik, The Nature of Explanation on the tree
1943
PeopleKenneth Craik
-
The Macy conferences on the tree
1946 to 1953
Grew fromA Logical Calculus of neurons, Behavior, Purpose and Teleology
PeopleG. Evelyn Hutchinson, Gregory Bateson, Heinz von Foerster, John von Neumann, Margaret Mead, Norbert Wiener, Walter Pitts, Warren McCulloch
-
A Logical Calculus of neurons on the tree
1943
PeopleWalter Pitts, Warren McCulloch
-
Ratio Club, Grey Walter's tortoises on the tree
1948 to 1958
Grew fromCraik, The Nature of Explanation, Wiener, Cybernetics (partial)
PeopleAlan Turing, John Bates, W. Grey Walter, W. Ross Ashby
-
Behavior, Purpose and Teleology on the tree
1943
Grew fromMilieu intérieur to homeostasis, Servomechanisms at MIT
PeopleArturo Rosenblueth, Julian Bigelow, Norbert Wiener
PaperBehavior, Purpose and Teleology
-
A Mathematical Theory of Communication on the tree
1948
Grew fromFeedback amplifiers (partial)
PeopleClaude Shannon
-
Von Neumann's automata on the tree
1944 to 1948
Grew fromA Logical Calculus of neurons
PeopleJohn von Neumann
-
Wiener, Cybernetics on the tree
1948
Grew fromBehavior, Purpose and Teleology, Maxwell, On Governors, The Macy conferences
PeopleNorbert Wiener
PaperCybernetics, the introduction
First branches 1950s to 1970s · 14
-
Bateson: the double bind, an ecology of mind on the tree
1956 to 1972
Grew fromThe Macy conferences
PeopleDon D. Jackson, Gregory Bateson, Jay Haley, John Weakland
PaperForm, Substance and Difference
-
Management cybernetics, the VSM on the tree
1959 to 1972
Grew fromAshby, requisite variety
PeopleStafford Beer
PaperThe Viable System Model
-
Modern control theory on the tree
1956 to 1960
Grew fromServomechanisms at MIT, Wiener, Cybernetics (partial)
PeopleLev Pontryagin, Richard Bellman, Rudolf Kalman
-
1971 to 1973
Grew fromManagement cybernetics, the VSM
PeopleFernando Flores, Stafford Beer
-
The name "artificial intelligence" on the tree
1955 to 1956
Grew fromA Logical Calculus of neurons (partial), Von Neumann's automata (partial)
PeopleClaude Shannon, John McCarthy, Marvin Minsky, Nathaniel Rochester
-
Ecosystems as loops on the tree
1948 to 1981
Grew fromThe Macy conferences
PeopleEugene Odum, G. Evelyn Hutchinson, Howard T. Odum
-
Every Good Regulator on the tree
1970
Grew fromAshby, requisite variety
PeopleRoger Conant, W. Ross Ashby
PaperEvery Good Regulator of a System Must Be a Model of That System
-
General systems theory on the tree
1954 to 1968
Grew fromThe Macy conferences (partial)
PeopleAnatol Rapoport, Kenneth Boulding, Ludwig von Bertalanffy, Ralph Gerard
-
Information theory on the tree
1949 to 1956
Grew fromA Mathematical Theory of Communication
PeopleClaude Shannon, Warren Weaver
-
Man-Computer Symbiosis on the tree
1960
Grew fromThe Macy conferences, Wiener, Cybernetics
PeopleJ. C. R. Licklider
-
The Limits to Growth on the tree
1972
Grew fromSystem dynamics
PeopleDennis Meadows, Donella Meadows, Jørgen Randers, William Behrens
-
1958 to 1969
Grew fromA Logical Calculus of neurons
PeopleFrank Rosenblatt
-
Soviet cybernetics on the tree
1954 to 1970s
Grew fromWiener, Cybernetics
PeopleAlexey Lyapunov, Anatoly Kitov, Sergei Sobolev, Viktor Glushkov
-
1956 to 1971
Grew fromServomechanisms at MIT, Wiener, Cybernetics (contested)
PeopleJay Forrester
Second order 1967 to 1990s · 11
-
1972 to 1980
Grew fromVon Foerster, the observer inside
PeopleFrancisco Varela, Humberto Maturana, Ricardo Uribe
PaperAutopoiesis
-
Radical constructivism on the tree
1974 to 1995
Grew fromVon Foerster, the observer inside
PeopleErnst von Glasersfeld
PaperOn Constructing a Reality
-
1991
Grew fromAutopoiesis
PeopleEleanor Rosch, Evan Thompson, Francisco Varela
-
Luhmann's social systems on the tree
1984
Grew fromAutopoiesis (contested)
PeopleNiklas Luhmann
-
Mead, Cybernetics of Cybernetics on the tree
1967, printed 1968
Grew fromBateson: the double bind, an ecology of mind, The Macy conferences
PeopleMargaret Mead
PaperCybernetics of Cybernetics
-
Morin's complex thought on the tree
1977 to 2004
Grew fromInformation theory (partial), Von Foerster, the observer inside
PeopleEdgar Morin
PaperRestricted Complexity, General Complexity
-
Nelson's hypertext on the tree
1965 to 1974
Grew fromPask's conversation theory, Whole Earth, counterculture (partial)
PeopleTed Nelson
-
Pask's conversation theory on the tree
1953 to 1980
Grew fromManagement cybernetics, the VSM, Von Foerster, the observer inside
PeopleGordon Pask, Ranulph Glanville
PaperDevelopments in Conversation Theory
-
Rittel's wicked problems on the tree
1967 to 1973
Grew fromGeneral systems theory (partial)
PeopleHorst Rittel
-
Von Foerster, the observer inside on the tree
1958 to 1979
Grew fromAshby, requisite variety, The Macy conferences
PeopleHeinz von Foerster
PaperCybernetics of Cybernetics
-
Whole Earth, counterculture on the tree
1968 to 1976
Grew fromBateson: the double bind, an ecology of mind
PeopleStewart Brand
On the shelf today now · 12
-
Cognitive science, extended mind on the tree
1990s to now
Grew fromBateson: the double bind, an ecology of mind (partial), Craik, The Nature of Explanation (partial), The Embodied Mind
PeopleAndy Clark, David Chalmers, Evan Thompson
-
Complexity science on the tree
1984 to now
Grew fromMorin's complex thought (partial), Wiener, Cybernetics (contested)
PeopleGeorge Cowan, Murray Gell-Mann
-
Neural nets, deep learning on the tree
1986 to now
Grew fromThe perceptron
PeopleDavid Rumelhart, Geoffrey Hinton, Ronald Williams
-
Family and systemic therapy on the tree
1958 to now
Grew fromBateson: the double bind, an ecology of mind
PeopleDon D. Jackson, Paul Watzlawick
-
The free energy principle on the tree
2006 to now
Grew fromCraik, The Nature of Explanation (partial), Every Good Regulator
PeopleAnil Seth, Karl Friston
-
Interaction design, HCI on the tree
1960s to now
Grew fromMan-Computer Symbiosis, Nelson's hypertext, Pask's conversation theory, Rittel's wicked problems (partial), Whole Earth, counterculture (partial)
PeopleHugh Dubberly, Paul Pangaro, Ranulph Glanville
PaperCybernetics and Design
-
Entropy, coding, compression on the tree
1948 to now
Grew fromInformation theory
-
Organizational design on the tree
1972 to now
Grew fromManagement cybernetics, the VSM, Project Cybersyn (partial)
PeopleStafford Beer
-
Reinforcement learning on the tree
1980s to now
Grew fromModern control theory, Ratio Club, Grey Walter's tortoises (partial)
PeopleAndrew Barto, Richard Sutton
-
Robotics and control on the tree
1984 to now
Grew fromModern control theory, Ratio Club, Grey Walter's tortoises
PeopleRodney Brooks, Valentino Braitenberg
-
Control loops in software on the tree
2014 to now
Grew fromEvery Good Regulator (partial), Modern control theory
-
1990 to now
Grew fromGeneral systems theory (partial), The Limits to Growth
PeopleDonella Meadows, Peter Senge
Talks, papers, books and my posts
The talks on the watching path, the papers the primers cover, the books on my reading shelf and my own posts, each with the ideas it sits on and who speaks in it or wrote it. Which work goes with which idea is my placing, not a claim about the field. A name opens it in the graph above.
Talks 4
-
In A World of Systems the video on the watching path
Donella Meadows
SpeakingDonella Meadows
AboutSystems thinking
-
The Future of Cybernetics | Paul Pangaro the video on the watching path
Worlds Fair Nano
SpeakingPaul Pangaro
Opens ontoQuestions for Conversation Theory
-
The Strange Math That Predicts (Almost) Anything the video on the watching path
Veritasium
-
Truth and Trust: Maturana and Von Foerster the video on the watching path
American Society for Cybernetics - ASC
SpeakingHeinz von Foerster, Humberto Maturana
AboutAutopoiesis, Von Foerster, the observer inside
Opens ontoOn Constructing a Reality
Papers with a primer 16
-
Varela, Maturana and Uribe, 1974
BehindAutopoiesis
-
Behavior, Purpose and Teleology the primer
Rosenblueth, Wiener and Bigelow, 1943
-
Cybernetics and Design the primer
Dubberly and Pangaro, 2015
BehindInteraction design, HCI
-
Cybernetics of Cybernetics the primer
Margaret Mead, 1968
-
Cybernetics of Cybernetics the primer
Heinz von Foerster, 1979
-
Cybernetics, the introduction the primer
Norbert Wiener, 1948
BehindWiener, Cybernetics
-
Developments in Conversation Theory the primer
Gordon Pask, 1980
-
Ethics and Second-Order Cybernetics the primer
Heinz von Foerster, 1991
-
Every Good Regulator of a System Must Be a Model of That System the primer
Conant and Ashby, 1970
BehindEvery Good Regulator
-
Form, Substance and Difference the primer
Gregory Bateson, 1970
-
On Constructing a Reality the primer
Heinz von Foerster, 1973
BehindRadical constructivism
-
Questions for Conversation Theory the primer
Paul Pangaro, 2017
-
W. Ross Ashby, 1956
BehindAshby, requisite variety
-
Restricted Complexity, General Complexity the primer
Edgar Morin, 2006
BehindMorin's complex thought
-
The Viable System Model the primer
Stafford Beer, 1984
-
What Is Conversation? the primer
Dubberly and Pangaro, 2009
Books on my shelf 1
-
The Human Use of Human Beings: Cybernetics and Society on the reading shelf
Norbert Wiener, reading now
On the mapNorbert Wiener
My posts 11
-
Gentler On-Ramps to Cybernetics read it
AboutOrganizational design, Project Cybersyn, Systems thinking
-
Making Complexity Visible: You Cannot Simplify the Ocean, Only Chart It read it
AboutComplexity science
-
The Information by James Gleick: The Book That Sent Me Looking for Meaning read it
AboutA Mathematical Theory of Communication, Entropy, coding, compression
Labs, schools and conferences
The places in Dubberly’s graph, with the people and groups he links to each and the ideas those people are named on. A place’s name opens it in the graph above.
Every place 23
-
Design Methods ConferenceWikipedia
LinkedBruce Archer, Christopher Alexander, Christopher Alexander, Chuck Owen, Design Thinking, Gordon Pask, Horst Rittel, London
Ideas of its peoplePask's conversation theory, Rittel's wicked problems
-
LinkedAlan Kay, Ed Catmull, Ivan Sutherland, James Clark, Jim Blinn, John Warnock
-
LinkedBob Taylor, Douglas Engelbart, Internet, Ivan Sutherland, J. C. R. Licklider
Ideas of its peopleMan-Computer Symbiosis
-
LinkedAlan Kay, Bill Atkinson, Larry Tesler, PARC
-
LinkedDesign Methods Conference, IIT Institute of Design, Soft Systems, Terry Winograd
-
LinkedBruce Archer, Gui Bonsiepe, Horst Rittel, Norbert Wiener
Ideas of its peopleBehavior, Purpose and Teleology, Rittel's wicked problems, The Macy conferences, Wiener, Cybernetics
-
LinkedBarbara Kuhr, John Plunkett, Kevin Kelly, Nicholas Negroponte
-
Biological Computer LaboratoryWikipedia
LinkedGordon Pask, Humberto Maturana, W. Ross Ashby
Ideas of its peopleAshby, requisite variety, Autopoiesis, Every Good Regulator, Pask's conversation theory, Ratio Club, Grey Walter's tortoises
-
LinkedARPA, Douglas Engelbart, Tim Berners-Lee
-
LinkedDesign Thinking, Don Koberg, Jim Bagnall
-
LinkedPaul Pangaro, Ranulph Glanville
Ideas of its peopleInteraction design, HCI (2), Pask's conversation theory
-
LinkedLarry Page, Sergey Brin
-
IIT Institute of DesignWikipedia
LinkedChuck Owen, Design Thinking
-
LinkedApple, Bob Taylor
-
LinkedChristopher Alexander
-
LinkedHorst Rittel
Ideas of its peopleRittel's wicked problems
-
LinkedNicholas Negroponte
-
LinkedKen Kesey
-
LinkedVannevar Bush
-
LinkedDouglas Engelbart
-
LinkedDouglas Engelbart
-
LinkedChristopher Alexander
Weight, my trail, and change over time
I borrowed a few words from calculus and neural nets to look at this map. They are simple counts and one small regression, nothing more, and this is what each word means here.
| Word | Here it means | Shown |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | how many independent sources record a line | the Evidence lens |
| Bias | how many marks my own trail puts on a node | the My trail lens |
| Derivative | the rate of change since last week’s snapshot | below |
| Integral | the running total across every weekly snapshot | below |
| Backpropagation | a small logistic regression that guesses what I will look at next and checks itself against what I did | kept private, off this site |
How a line gets its weight
| For each | Weight |
|---|---|
| source that records the line: Dubberly, the family tree, the primers, the watching path, the reading shelf, and Wikidata when it confirms one of Dubberly’s | +3 |
| two people who worked together, beside an influence or an affiliation | +1 |
| a lineage the sources only partly support | −1 |
| a lineage the sources dispute | −2 |
| my placing: a talk, book or post on an idea, what a talk opens onto, the paper behind an idea | 0 |
| Drawn as | Lines |
|---|---|
| Faint: one source, and the sources only partly agree or dispute it | 25 |
| Plain: one source records it | 303 |
| Strong: two sources agree | 42 |
| Strongest: two sources agree on two people who worked together, or three agree | 10 |
| No evidence weight: my placing, drawn plain | 34 |
Week to week
Each week a snapshot counts every node’s lines by source and the marks my trail puts on it, and keeps it in the repo. The change column is this week against 2026-W46.
| Count | Now | Change since last week | Running total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lines from the family tree | 304 | 0 | 1216 |
| Lines from the primers | 40 | 0 | 160 |
| Lines from the math | 59 | 0 | 236 |
| Lines from the reading shelf | 16 | 0 | 63 |
| Lines from the watching path | 15 | 0 | 60 |
| Lines from Dubberly’s graph | 169 | 0 | 676 |
| Marks on my trail (mine) | 45 | 0 | 180 |
Most marks on my trail, summed week by weekSystems thinking (12), Entropy, coding, compression (8), Pask's conversation theory (8), A Mathematical Theory of Communication (8), Control loops in software (8)
Each line is counted once. Visits to these pages will join the snapshot when a weekly count of them is kept in the repo; for now it holds the map alone.
In numbers
| Layer | On the graph |
|---|---|
| Ideas | 52 |
| People | 128 |
| Labs, schools and conferences | 23 |
| Papers with a primer | 16 |
| Talks, books and my posts | 16 |
| Line | From | Count |
|---|---|---|
| Lineage between ideas | the family tree | 76 |
| Named on an idea | the family tree | 107 |
| Worked together | Dubberly’s Social Graph of Cybernetics | 90 |
| Influence | Dubberly’s Social Graph of Cybernetics | 26 |
| Organizations and events | Dubberly’s Social Graph of Cybernetics | 53 |
| Wrote | the primers | 23 |
| The paper behind an idea | the primers | 13 |
| A talk, book or post about an idea | the watching path, the reading shelf and the family tree, my placing | 19 |
| Speaks in a talk | the watching path | 4 |
| Wrote a book on my shelf | the reading shelf | 1 |
| A talk that opens onto a paper | the watching path | 2 |
Ideas and lineage as checked for the family tree; people’s lines as Dubberly publishes them, with a ✓ where Wikidata also records one. Who wrote a paper comes from the primers’ own credits. A book is joined to a person only when its author line names them exactly. My trail marks 37 of them and adds no line.
The other maps: the family tree, the ideas and their lineage · the people, who worked with whom · the cybernetics map, what covers each idea · the watching path, the talks in order